Cash Grain Commentary by Cash Grain Bids Inc  

  Soybean Carry Vanishes

 

Most of this month, soybean futures have traded up and down within a 30 cent range. But this week, prices closed lower, hitting a new low for the month. Export numbers met analyst's expectations this week, coming in at 34.2 million bushels. The pace of exports, however, continues to lag behind the historical average. Cumulative inspections are now 24% of the USDA forecast for the season, compared to the five year average of 31% for this time of the year. If this slow export pace continues, the USDA may be pushed to lower their export forecast in coming months.

Weather in South America continues to play on the market. Planting progress is now at 46% and 62% complete in Argentina and Brazil respectively. Northern Brazil received some much needed rain this past weekend, and more rain is in the forecast. Weather premiums are already built into the market, as traders predicted dry conditions across most of Argentina and Brazil. Increased moisture could quickly erode the weather premium, pushing futures lower.

While futures have stumbled, basis has been strong, pushing up cash prices for many producers. In most all of the major soybean producing states, cash prices are higher this month than last. On average, cash prices are up 26 cents across Iowa. Prices rose 20 cents in Illinois and sixteen cents in Indiana. For all three of these states, the current price is now higher than last year's price.

Average Soybean Prices
State Current Last Month Last Year
AL 525 532 525
AR 572 544 562
IA 536 510 528
IL 554 534 546
IN 546 530 534
KS 512 509 502
KY 560 529 555
LA 560 554 559
MI 526 523 516
MN 523 500 526
MO 544 520 524
MS 543 527 547
NC 541 542 522
ND 510 506 509
NE 523 508 510
OH 537 527 527
OK 524 516 519
PA 514 523 497
SD 514 496 514
TX 492 494 484
WI 512 499 514

Lower transportation costs continue to help basis. Both rail and trucking rates were down this week, with trucking rates falling 3%. Trucking rates are down 17% compared to last month. Barge rates edged up 5% this week but are still down 42% from last month. In recent weeks, river locations have experienced the strongest increases in basis. This could come to an end if barge rates have bottomed and are now moving higher.

Last month, as the harvest pushed towards an end and corn was being piled up on the ground, cash prices were 15 to 30 cents lower. Elevators, lacking storage, were offering significant premiums for deferred delivery. In many cases it was possible to lock in 20 to 30 cents of carry by contracting into January or March. With low spot prices, the majority of farmers decided to hold their grain and wait for a price recovery. Now a month later, basis has been bid up as elevators attempt to entice farmers to sell. While spot prices have moved higher, forward delivery prices have not.

There is currently a positive 7 cent spread between January and March soybean futures, however, carry in the cash market is nearly gone and in some cases it is now negative. In Illinois there is no premium for contracting into December or January and in Iowa soybeans contracted for December and January are selling for three and six cents less than the spot price. Carry is also negative in Arkansas, Missouri, and Ohio.

Soybean Forward Delivery Premium/Discount
State Dec Jan Feb Mar
AR -3 -7 -5 -8
IA -3 -6 -4 0
IL 0 0 1 2
IN 0 0 1 3
KS 0 0 8 12
KY 3 4 5 3
MN 1 2 5 8
MO -2 -2 -3 -3
NE 1 0 6 9
OH -2 0 -1 -4
OK 0 13 7 7
SD 2 6 7 8

Grain elevators want you to sell your grain today. They are actively bidding up their basis to draw grain off the farm and into the elevator. They are no longer offering any incentives for storing grain. If farmers continue to hold out for higher prices soybean basis could move even higher, but with negative carry in the market it becomes considerably more risky to store your grain. At some point producers will start selling their grain to take advantage of the recent increase in basis. This could cause basis to move lower again. It is a tricky balance. You can hold out for an even higher price, but you definitely do not want to be the last one standing in line at the elevator if everyone else decides to sell.

sales@cashgrainbids.com
©2005 CashGrainBids.com, Cash Grain Bids Inc. | All Rights Reserved.